|
THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE: Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting to the Plan Commission to
order at 7:11 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present at this discuss were Commissioners Kelley, Dybdahl, and Sova, City
Planner Tetzlaff, City Engineer Vanden Noven, City Administrator Grams,
(arriving at 7:26 p.m.) and City Building Inspector Wiese. Absent and
Excused: Commissioner Ewig and Alderman Babcock. City Planner Tetzlaff
informed the Commissioners that he had emailed the PDO (Planned
Development Overlay District) and WFO (Westland Floodplain Overlay
District) to each of them for their review. Discussion was again on the
height of buildings in the downtown area. City Engineer Vanden Noven
stated that he had research the height of the downtown buildings. He
looked at the 1980's and 1990's. He stated that in 1989 the height of
buildings were lower from 85 feet to 35 feet. The tallest building in the
downtown area is the Courthouse. It is 136 feet above the sidewalk to the
eagle. The Har borside Hotel and Harbor Square's new development tie for
second tallest at 61 feet. The 3rd tallest building is
Lueptow's at 55 feet plus 5 feet for the elevator. Sir James Pub comes in
4th at 45 feet. Commissioners continued their discussion on
height in the downtown area. City Planner Tetzlaff stated that he was in
favor of the Mayor's suggestion of an ordinance for one area only and
never uses it again, sort of like a "Sunset Clause." Commissioner Dybdahl
stated that, that was too much like spot zoning. Commissioner Sova stated
that he didn't like the 65 feet. It was too high.
1. Roll Call FOR REGULAR MEETING: Mayor Gottlieb
called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to order at 7:32
p.m. All members were present except Alderman Babcock and Commissioner
Ewig.
2. Approval of Minutes OF NOVEMBER 21 MEETING: MOTION
BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to
approve the minutes as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
Commissioner Kelley wanted to know if Beanies' outdoor seating was coming
back to the Plan Commission. The videotape of the November meeting would
be reviewed.
3. Chairman’s Business – aPPOINTMENT TO THE SMART
GROWTH ADVISORY COMMITTEE: The County is establishing committee in
County and Local Smart Growth. Every community in Ozaukee County is being
asked to appoint a representative for this Advisory Committee. Mayor
Gottlieb suggested Randy Tetzlaff. City Planner Tetzlaff suggested a City
Official or a Plan Commissioner should be on the Advisory Committee. No
date has been set for the Advisory Committee to meeting, but it should be
some time in late January or early February. More information should be
forthcoming and the Plan Commissioner will be advised.
4. PUBLIC APPEARANCE AND COMMENTS: There was none.
5. CONSENT AGENDA:
A. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND MINOR FAÇADE IMPROVEMENTS AT
301 W. GRAND AVENUE, TENG ASSOCIATES, APPLICANT: City Planner Tetzlaff
informed the Commissioners that back in November, the Design Review Board
requested the applicant to make revisions to the proposed façade changes.
A request was made to relocate a proposed louvered vent from the front
elevation and attempts be made to improve the aesthetics of the front
elevation. The applicant is before you tonight with a revised plan. The
revised plan has moved the vent to the east elevation and the front canopy
has been removed and replaced with a skewed roof. Everyone concurs that
the building's modern façade is non-descript with little or no character.
Other alternatives were explored and discussed and those changes to the
façade merely look as if they are pasted on. The Board felt that adding
some landscaping might improve the appearance of the building.
Unfortunately, the building sits on the front lot line and there is no
room in the front. Staff recommends approval of the proposed façade
improvement subject to the addition of a 3 foot landscaped area along the
east side of the building. The Board of Review agreed with the
recommendation, except for City Building Inspection Dennis Wiese. City
Building Inspection Wiese was not happy with the revised plan. He thought
that the applicant could have come up with several better designs to dress
up the building and that the applicant made a superficial effort. Scott
Moesler of Teng Associates was present to answer any questions the
Commissioner might have. Commissioner discussed this item. It was agreed
to move the stack to the south side of the building. Commissioner Sova
agreed with City Building Inspector Wiese. MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND
SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to approve the proposed façade
improvements subject to the addition of a 3 foot landscaped area along the
east side of the building and placing the stack on the south side of the
building. Motion carried 4 to 1 (Gottlieb, Dybdahl, Kelly and Vanden
Noven voted aye; Sova voted nay).
6. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND COMMUNICATION TOWER AND
EQUIPMENT BUILDING AT 700 SUNSET ROAD, WE ENERGIES, APPLICANT: City
Planner Tetzlaff informed the Commissioner that WE Energies current
communication unit is attached to one of the existing smokestacks. The
stacks are to be removed as part of the conversion project; a new location
for communications is needed. Several alternatives sites were reviewed
including co-location on the Ozaukee County tower and the best location is
at their service center property located on Sunset Road. It is an
industrial area; there are wetlands on the north and only a minimal amount
of residential in the area. WE Energies is requesting to construct a 270'
lattice tower near the northwest corner of the service center. A small
pre-cast equipment building would be erected immediately south of the new
tower. Only site plan approval is required for communication towers. The
property is zoned B-2 and not PUL, I-1 or I-2; a conditional use grant is
not required as per a recent zoning ordinance amendment. The Design Review
Board was not particularly happy about allowing another cell tower in the
City, felt that only some landscaping or screening provisions could be
required to mitigate the impact of the tower. Commissioners asked if the
could place antennas on the south side water tower. WE Energies stated
that it was not high enough and the County tower was full and would not
accept a 3rd party to use their tower. City Engineer Vanden
Noven asked what if we could deny their site plan if it is a permitted
use. Mayor Gottlieb stated that he did not know if it was a permitted or
an accessory use. City Planner Tetzlaff stated that all the other previous
communication towers were permitted uses of site plan approval. MOTION
BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY Commissioner Sova to table this item and
request an opinion from the City Attorney as to whether is a permitted use
at this site. Motion carried unanimously. This item will come back
in January 2003.
7. PUBLIC HEARING REGARDING AMENDMENTS TO THE 2020 CITY
LAND USE PLAN MAP: Mayor Gottlieb declared opened the Public Hearing
at 8:30 p.m. City Planner Tetzlaff reviewed this item with the
Commissioners. He reviewed the area of Sauk Creek, Schanen Farm South,
Town of Grafton by Sauk Road and the area joint City and Town Land Use
discussion. Jeff Herrenbruck of 3164 Green Bay Road was concerned about
the pond and land around his house. The road to his home changes according
to the weather. City Planner Tetzlaff invited Mr. Hernbrook to come to his
office and he would discuss the changes with him. MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to close
the public hearing at 8:40 p.m. Motion carried unanimously.
8. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND AMENDMENTS TO THE 2020 CITY
LAND USE PLAN MAP: City Planner Tetzlaff reviewed this item with the
Commissioners. He also stated to the Commissioners that the Town had
contacted him and they had some minor changes that they wanted to make on
the item 4 regarding the joint agreement. The Town asked that we not take
action of that amendment. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY
COMMISSIONER KELLEY to table this item. Motion carried unanimously.
9. PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS:
CONTINUED DISCUSSION ON UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT
ORDINANCE: City Planner Tetzlaff wanted to if the Commissioner
wanted to meet on Thursday, January 2, 2003 to discuss the United
Development Ordinance. It was mention at the last meeting that the
Plan Commission should meet on the 1st and 3rd
Thursday to try and complete the Unified Development Ordinance.
Commissioner agreed to meet on the 2nd of January.
Commissioners continued to discuss the height in the downtown area.
The Mayor suggested that height discussion should comeback with a
specific recommendation that has been legally reviewed. The
Commissioners preferences is that they only want 85 feet where it
already exists, physical exists like the Lighthouse Condos, do not
want to create non-conforming with existing buildings over 35 feet
in the downtown and you want to come up with something that will
make that happen. You want to protect the property above the 35 feet
in the downtown and you want the best way to do that. City Planner
Tetzlaff reviewed the PDO, Planned Development Overly District with
the Commissioners in detail. They discussed the WFO, Wetland
Floodplain Overlay District.
10. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES: Merton Lueptow of
959 West Whitefish Road discussed the height issue in the downtown area.
He suggested make the height limit in the downtown a permitted use by
right and have it at 64 feet or 65 feet. Then eliminate all the variances
and then grandfather those few buildings that are above that height limit.
Lloyd Smith of 1312 West Grand Avenue wanted to clarify one thing. He
thought that when the Lighthouse Condo site was approved, it was the
intent of the Plan Commission not to have an overlay, 85 feet at that site
and 35 feet at all other sites.
11. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS
AUTHORIZED BY LAW: There was none.
12. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND
SECOND BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY to adjourn the meeting at 9:10 p.m.
Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 21, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting to the Plan Commission to
order at 7:05 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present were Commissioners Kelley, Dybdahl, and Ewig, Alderman Babcock,
City Planner Tetzlaff, City Engineer Vanden Noven, and City Building
Inspector Wiese. Absent and Excused: Commissioner Sova and City
Administrator Grams. City Planner Tetzlaff informed the Commissioners that
this project is moving slower than he had hoped. Staff and the
Commissioners are working well together, but he had hoped to have this
project finished before the Mayor's career in Port was finished. The
Commission is committed to this project and must stay on task. The
Commissioners decided to have a second meeting in the month for an hour or
two to work on this project. The first Thursday of the month was chosen to
work on the Unified Development Ordinance beginning in January. Discussion
on the height of the downtown district was discussed.
Roll Call FOR REGULAR MEETING: Mayor Gottlieb
called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to order at 7:38
p.m. All members were present except Commissioner Sova and City
Administrator Mark Grams.
Approval of Minutes OF OCTOBER 17th MEETING: MOTION BY
ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve the minutes
as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
Chairman’s Business: There was none.
Public Appearances & Comments: There was none.
consent agenda:
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND LONG-TERM TEMPORARY SIGN FOR
LINCOLN VILLAGE SENIOR APARTMENTS, MSP REAL ESTATE, APPLICANT: The
Plan Commission previously approved this sign to be located on the
property located at 1317 West Grand Avenue, owned by Mike Ansay. That
sign was not erected and Mr. Ansay is no longer interested in having it
on his property. Many prospective tenants of the Lincoln Village are
mistakenly turning into the private drive between the Ansay property and
Culvers. The proposed sign was meant to direct people to Summit Drive
and then on to Lincoln Avenue. The owners of Culvers have granted
permission to erect the sign on the west edge of their property. A
letter from the owners is enclosed in the packet. The maximum duration
is 9 months and the leasing agent has indicated that if the project were
fully leased before that time, the sign would be removed. Staff
recommends approval to erect a long-term temporary sign, 4 feet by 8
feet in size, on Culver's property; to be constructed using decorative
posts; to be no higher than 2 feet above the ground; the red arrow be
removed from the sign; and that the sign shall be removed no later than
the time the apartment project is leased or in nine months. Mayor
Gottlieb suggested that the agent for Lincoln Village check with the
Department of Transportation, District 2, regarding regulation of signs
on a state highway, the permitted uses and setbacks. MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER EWIG AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to approve
the sign as presented with staff recommendations and subjected to
checking with the Department of Transportation on setbacks and permits.
Motion carried unanimously. (NOTE: the WDOT office has been
contacted and has no objections to the erection of the sign.)
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND FAÇADE AND SITE IMPROVMENTS AT
100-102 WEST GRAND AVENUE, HAAG MULLER, ARCHITECTS, APPLICANT: City
Planner Tetzlaff informed the Commissioners that the owners' of Beanie's
plan to convert the adjacent tavern building and their current
restaurant into Beanie's Restaurant and Cantina. Mike Muller of Haag
Muller Architects reviewed the renovation plan with the Commissioners.
The renovation plans call for a new interior, façade renovation, and
improved parking. New outdoor seating on the sidewalk is also proposed
to replace the dining area currently in the parking lot, which would
again revert to customer parking. The crème city brick exterior of the
corner building would be restored and the adjacent one-story cinder
block building would be refaced and both buildings would be tied
together with strong horizontal lines. New awnings would also be added
to tie the structures together. A new sign would be over the corner
entrance. The Design Review Board recommends approval of the façade
renovation and the concept of outdoor dining on the street. They also
suggested the other appropriate boards and commissions review and
approve the use of the sidewalk for outside dining. Commissioner agreed
that this was great looking project, but some had concerns about the
outside dining. MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY
COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve the site plan for the renovation of the two
buildings. The outdoor dining is subject to the approval of the Board of
Public Works and the Common Council. Motion Carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT FOR THE
FORMER SCHANEN PROPERTY, SOUTH OF STH 33: City Planner Tetzlaff
informed the Commissioners that the Common Council discussed the possible
development of the former Schanen farm, south of STH 33, during their
November 6th meeting. While there was no specific decision made
on selling the property now, the Council gave the go ahead for staff to
discuss sewer service boundaries with the Village of Saukville and for the
Plan Commission to review the a land use plan amendment for the area.
Commissioners discussed various types of residential developments for this
area. MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY to
show support for the approval of recommending that the Land Use Plan be
amended to change the former Schanen farm property (south) from "park and
open space" to "low density residential and park/open space." The exact
size and location of the park area would be left undetermined. The change
would also include a "green space" buffer at the corner of STH 33 and
Jackson Road. Motion carried unanimously. A public hearing will be
held on December 19, 2002.
TOWN OF PORT WASHINGTON LAND USE PLAN UPDATE: City
Planner Tetzlaff discussed this issue with the Commissioners. He stated
that the Town Plan Commission met on November 13th to discuss
the joint land use plan. There was agreement with all of our
recommendations except for Area #18. We suggested that "business park" be
extended west to the sanitary sewer boundary. Previously, that area was
designed "urban residential." The Town would prefer that the area be shown
as "either business park or urban residential." There was concern as to
how a city business park would buffer adjacent to rural residential. The
Town is planning on holding a public hearing on December 11th
and take official action on the joint plan. They also identified several
other issues that also need to be considered after the joint plan is
adopted. They are: revenue sharing, cost estimates of possible
infrastructure, procedural framework of a border agreement, interim plan -
can landowners continue to develop their properties, possible town
moratorium in the Knellsville area, cost sharing, and next meeting
schedule - possible subcommittee of joint town and city officials and
staff. The Town Board is expected to hold a special meeting to discuss in
more details these issues. Mayor Gottlieb stated that a close eye should
be kept on jurisdiction and land use. We now have agreement and Plan
Commission has done the job asked of them. City staff recommends that the
City concur with the joint land use designation of a portion of Area #18,
and city staff also recommends that the Plan Commission defer discussion
of the other issues raised by the Town to the Common Council. MOTION BY
MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY COMMISSION KELLEY to approve the
recommendation by city staff that the City concur with the joint
land use designation of a portion of Area #18, and city staff also
recommends that the Plan Commission defer discussion of the other issues
raised by the Town to the Common Council. Motion carried unanimously.
SMART GROWTH LAND USE UPDATE: City Planner Tetzlaff
informed the Commissioners that the Smart Growth law requires local units
of government to adopt comprehensive plans by 2010 that address nine land
use issues and tailor their ordinances to that plan. The Southeastern
Wisconsin Regional Planning Commission (SEWRPC) has advised that once the
Regional Plan is completed, their agency will work with each county to
develop a plan. Local communities can then prepare their respective plans
afterward or work concurrently with the development of the county plan.
Working with the county may make available some grant money to help with
the preparation. In a recent Journal-Sentinel article, the Ozaukee County
Smart Growth Committee has recommended that SEWRPC be hired to prepare the
county plan. It is proposed that a citizen-based advisory committee be
appointed to work with the county. Representatives would be either elected
officials or plan commissioners from each of the fourteen municipalities
in the county. In addition, an ad-hoc work group would also be formed
comprised of municipal staff planners. City Planner Tetzlaff also informed
the Commissioners that the County would be holding a public hearing on
January 14, 2003 at 7:00 p.m. No action is required tonight, but City
Planner Tetzlaff suggested the Commission might want to think about who
would want to be on this advisory committee and where do we fit in the
Smart Growth. Mayor Gottlieb would like a name by next month's plan
commission meeting so that he may take it to the Common Council for
approval.
PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS:
CONTINUED DISCUSSION ON UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT
ORDINANCE: The Commissioner revisited the height issue in the
downtown area. It was suggested that the buildings in the downtown area
be measured by the City Engineer and an average be brought back to the
plan commission for discussion. The Shoreland/Wetland Ordinance was
discussed.
10. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES: There was none.
11. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS AUTHORIZED BY LAW: Commissioner Kelley would like the
email address of the City Staff.
12. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY to adjourn the meeting at 9:05 p.m.
Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, OCTOBER 17, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting to the Plan Commission to
order at 7:04 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present at this discussion were Commissioners Sova, Dybdahl, and Ewig,
Alderman Babcock, City Administrator Grams, City Planner Tetzlaff, City
Engineer Vanden Noven, and City Building Inspector Wiese. Absent and
Excused: Commissioner Kelley. Commissioners discussed the height issue in
the downtown area. Alderman Babcock wanted to eliminate the 85 ft.
building height. Commissioners were asked to think about this issue for
next month's meeting. Also discussed were the OB4 and OB5 districts. Mayor
Gottlieb like the idea of the OB4 with Conditional Use Grants.
Commissioner Sova agreed. Arterial Gateway and Plan Development Districts
were discussed. The Shoreland Ordinance was also discussed. Discussion
ended at 7:28 p.m.
1. ROLL CALL FOR REGULAR MEETING: Mayor Gottlieb
called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to order at 7:30
p.m. All members were present except Commissioner Kelley. Commissioner
Kelley was absent and excused.
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF SEPTEMBER 12TH AND
19TH: MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER
EWIG to approve the minutes as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
3. CHAIRMAN'S BUSINESS: There was none.
4. PUBLIC APPEARANCES & COMMENTS: There was none.
5. CONSENT AGENDA:
REVIEW AND APPROVE FAÇADE MODIFICATION FOR
BOUCHER CHEVROLET AT 1180 S. SPRING STREET, PROFESSIONAL
CONSULTANTS, INC., APPLICANT: City Planner Tetzlaff informed the
Commissioners that the Boucher Chevrolet would like to reface a
portion of the front façade of the dealership building. They would
like to cover the blue metal facing on the upper portion of the
building façade. Also a new blue logo unit would be built in the
front entry. The new logo is part of Chevrolet's new international
look. The Design Review Board recommended approval. MOTION BY
CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to
approve the façade modifications as presented. Motion carried
unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE SITE PLAN FOR NATURAL AREA
IMPROVEMENTS AT THE NORTHWEST CORNER OF W. GRAND AVE. AND N. WEBSTER
STREET, FIRST CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH, APPLICANT: Susan Skowbo and
Andy Weber from the First Congregational Church appeared before Plan
Commission. They presented a plan for a partnership between the City
and the Church to clean up and make more accessible the city-owned
land along Sauk Creek and adjacent to the West Grand Avenue bridge.
A subcommittee of the church prepared the plan. This plan has been
reviewed by City Staff. The Design Review Board and the Park and
Recreation Board have recommended approval. The Plan includes
developing a memorial garden on church property adjacent to the
city-owned lands. The retaining wall would be removed. Additional
fill would be added to create a natural amphitheater with a
comfortable slope. There would be direct access from the bridge to
the creek area for a "quiet area". Part of this new park would be
handicapped accessible. This would be a new park for the City with
direct access to Sauk Creek. Commissioner Dybdahl questioned if
there was enough space. City Engineer Vanden Noven questioned the
lease agreement. MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY
COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve the Site Plan as presented.
Commissioner Sova questioned if this was a concept plan or site
plan. City Planner Tetzlaff stated it was a site plan. Motion
carried unanimously.
6. REVIEW AND APPROVE MONUMENT SIGN AT 101 W. GRAND
AVENUE, A.N. ANSAY, OWNER (PREVIOUSLY TABLED): City Planner Tetzlaff
informed the Commissioners that Mr. Tom Lubnar of Prime Cast Sign was
appearing again with a new sign. A mock-up of the new sign is across the
street next to the old bank sign. The new sign is 42" x 7'. MOTION BY
ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to approve the
new sign as presented. City Planner Tetzlaff asked if there was still a
reader board on the sign. He was informed that it was still on the sign.
Motion carried unanimously.
7. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT
AMENDMENT TO PERMIT RYDER TRUCK RENTAL AT 925 S. SPRING STREET, RAY
FLAHERTY, OWNER: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the
Commissioners that recently a CUG was granted for this property to allow
auto repairs and sales and installation of automotive accessories. The
owners are now requesting permission to rent moving trucks. Jon Ulik and
Amy Lawrence were present to answer any questions the Commissioner might
have. They explained to the Commissioners that Tires Unlimited is the only
other place in the City to rent trucks and they rent U-Haul. Precision
Auto would rent Ryder Trucks. There would be only one truck parked
outside. All others would be parked inside. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA
AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL to recommend approval to the Common
Council subject to the following conditions: 1) Only one truck parked
outside; and 2) All other trucks parked inside the facility. Commissioner
Ewig questioned the signage and the owners stated that there would be a
small sign in the window. Motion carried unanimously.
8. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND AMENDING ZONING ORDINANCE TO
ALLOW FRONT SETBACK AVERAGING: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff explained
to the Commissioners that the Board of Appeals is requesting that the
Zoning Ordinance be amended to allow front setback averaging. Several
properties along the east side of Powers Street have been granted front
setbacks variances and the City Building Inspector has noted that in the
older developed area of the City, many homes have been built closer to the
street than what is required in the prevailing zoning district. MOTION
BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to recommend
approval to the Common Council to change the language to read as follows:
Regardless of the minimum setback required by the zoning district, a
setback may be reduced to the mean of the setbacks of the immediately
adjoining lots that are on both sides of the subject lot. The following
rules apply in calculating the mean setback: a) Only the setbacks on lots
that abut the subject lot and are on the same side of the street may be
used. Setbacks across the street or along a different street may not be
used; and b) When one abutting lot is vacant, or if the lot is a corner
lot, then the average is mean of the setbacks of the non-vacant lot and
the zoning district minimum. The public hearing would be held on November
19th. Motion carried; (5 votes aye (Mayor Gottlieb, Ewig,
Babcock, Sova, Vanden Noven); 1 vote nay (Dybdahl)). The Mayor requested a
list of properties be presented at the public hearing.
9. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND AMENDING ZONING ORDINANCE
REGARDING THE ISSUANCE OF OCCUPANCY PERMITS: City Building Inspector
Dennis Wiese informed the Commissioners that several months ago this issue
was brought up during the Unified Development Ordinance discussion. The
concern was when a property is sold, or when a business changes hands,
while it may be a permitted use, it may not meet other applicable codes or
regulations. The Building Inspector would like to see himself and the Fire
Inspector inspect these premises prior to their occupancy to make sure
they comply with applicable codes and regulations. The Commissioner
discussed this issue and the Mayor asked that the Building Inspector write
up a draft ordinance with the City Attorney and bring it back to the Plan
Commission.
10. REVIEW AND APPROVE JOINT TOWN - CITY OF PORT
WASHINGTON LAND USE PLAN: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the
Commissioners that last month, the planners for the City and the Town were
directed to prepare a joint land use plan for the areas surrounding the
City. A draft has been prepared and is to be reviewed by the Town Planning
Commission during the week of October 7th. Commissioners
discussed the various areas. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED
BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to have the City Planner take back to the Town of
Port Washington and then to bring back to the Plan Commission for approval
of the following items: #18 move to the Sanitary Sewer Line; #2 keep
residential; #27 keep as a buffer on the west side (1 lot depth) from
manufacturing; and #3 keep as a buffer on the south side. Motion
carried unanimously.
11. REVIEW LAND USE PLAN AND CONSIDER OTHER
UPDATES/AMENDMENTS NOT COVERED BY THE JOINT TOWN – CITY OF PORT WASHINGTON
PLAN: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the Commissioners that the
Land Use Plan was updated or amended in December of 2000. The City needs
to review future land uses in the areas in the Town of Grafton (the area
southwest of STH 32 and East Sauk Road) that may become parts of the City
and some undeveloped areas within the City limits. The other issue to
discuss is whether to modify the terminology of our land use categories to
be compatible with the terminology in the Joint Town-City Land Use Plan.
The areas in the City to look at are Sauk Creek Corridor, Schanen Property
South and Lands in the Town of Grafton.
12. PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS:
CONTINUED DISCUSSION ON UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT
ORDINANCE: Discussion continued on the Shoreland Ordinance and
Flood Plain the downtown area. Also discussed was the bluff area.
The bike path is a jewel of the City. But the bluff area along the
bike path has chopped off trees, fill problems, property owners’ use
it as a dumpsite and this needs to be addressed.
13. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES: There was none.
14. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS
AUTHORIZED BY LAW: There was none.
15. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to adjourn the meeting at 9:15 p.m.
Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, SEPTMEBER 19,
2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPEMTN ORDINANCE:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to
order at 7:03 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present at this discussion were Commissioners Mark Dybdahl, Earl Kelley,
Gene Ewig, City Engineer Rob Vanden Noven, Alderman Burt Babcock, and City
Planner Randy Tetzlaff. City Administrator Mark Grams arrived at 7:28 p.m.
Commissioner Bud Sova and City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese were absent
and excused. City Planner Tetzlaff and the Commissioners continued with
their discussion on the Traditional Neighborhood Developments. They also
discussed Permitted Uses and Conditional Uses in various districts.
1. Roll Call FOR REGULAR MEETING: Mayor Gottlieb
called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to order at 7:30
p.m. Members present were Commissioners Mark Dybdahl, Earl Kelley, Gene
Ewig, City Engineer Rob Vanden Noven, Alderman Burt Babcock, City Planner
Randy Tetzlaff and City Administrator Mark Grams. Commissioner Bud Sova
and City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese were absent and excused.
2. Approval of Minutes OF AUGUST 15 MEETING: MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve the
minutes as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
3. Chairman’s Business: Mayor Gottlieb informed the
Commissioner that a joint meeting was held on Thursday, August 12, 2002
with the Town of Port Washington. The meeting went well and progress was
made. The City and the Town will begin the process of a preparing a joint
land use plan for the areas around the City.
4. PUBLIC APPEARANCES AND COMMENTS: There was none.
5. CONSENT AGENDA:
REVIEW AND APPROVE MINOR BUILDING FAÇADE
RESTORATION FOR 112 E. GRAND AVENUE, RICK DUGAN, OWNER: City
Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the Plan Commissioners that Mr.
Dugan has removed the wood from the front of the building and would
like to remove the old brick and replace it with crème city brick to
match the original brick. He would also like to build a brick
archway over the door and install awning like those across the
street at the Harbor Square building. The Design Review Board would
like to see the addition of a continuous flush brick soldier course
and a 1 inch protruding roll lock above the windows and terminating
at the archway above the doorway. Mr. Dugan stated that the soldier
effect would cost $6,000 and he would prefer the awnings. He stated
with the brickwork above the windows and having the awnings in
place, nobody would see the brickwork. Alderman Babcock stated that
the restoration of this building would look good in the downtown
area and he agreed with Mr. Dugan on the brickwork. MOTION BY
ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to
approve the minor building façade restoration as presented.
Commissioner Dybdahl stated that it was a nice improvement.
Motion carried unanimously.
6. REVIEW AND APPROVE MONUMENT SIGN AT 101 W. GRAND
AVENEUE, A.N. ANSAY, OWNER: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the
Commissioners that A. N. Ansay has purchased the former United Savings and
Loan building to be used for office space. Plans include removing the
existing pole sign and replacing it with a new monument sign, similar to
the Ansay sign located at 1317 West Grand Avenue. The new sign will be
constructed with a colorized aluminum finish. It will be illuminated and
will also have an attached electronic reader board. The sign face will be
approximately 56 square feet in size and 8 feet high. Atop the sign will
be a stylized "A", a logo for Ansay, that brings the entire sign height to
almost 14 feet. The Plan Commission must give special approval to
authorizing this sign because it exceeds the size limits of the B-4,
Central Business District (20 sq. ft.) The Design Review Board recommended
approval of this sign. Mr. Tom Lubnar of Prime Cast Sign was present to
answer any questions. Alderman Babcock stated he like the sign but was
concerned about the intersection. Commissioner Ewig questioned the size of
the sign. Commissioner Dybdahl was concerned about the sign being to close
to the road. Mayor Gottlieb stated that the setbacks were not an issue and
this was a signal-controlled intersection. Commissioners asked if the
message board scrolled. Mr. Lubnar stated that it does move and that he
and the Ansay Company were flexible to work with the City. Mayor Gottlieb
asked about the base of the sign. Mr. Lubnar stated it was sheet aluminum
with framing. Mayor Gottlieb asked if it could be brick on the bottom and
base to match the façade of the building. Mr. Lubnar stated that could be
done. MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN
NOVEN to approve the sign as presented but with a brick base. Commissioner
Dybdahl did not like the sign that close to the road. Commissioner Ewig
was not happy with the size of the sign. Commissioner Kelley stated it was
too big for the area. Alderman Babcock stated that it was double the
City's monument sign and that it was too big. City Engineer stated that
the sign was better than the pole sign. Motion Denied; (2 votes aye
(Gottlieb and Vanden Noven) 4 votes nays (Ewig, Babcock, Kelley, and
Dybdahl)). Commissioners discussed the sign again. MOTION BY ALDERMAN
BABCOCK to reduce the size of the sign to not to exceed 32 sq. ft.;
Motion dies for lack of a second. Commissioners again discussed the
sign. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to
table this item until the next meeting. Mayor Gottlieb informed the
Commissioners that the applicant should be informed as to what is
expected. Commissioners wanted a smaller sign. Motion carried; (5
votes aye (Ewig, Babcock, Dybdahl, Kelley, Vanden Noven) 1 vote nay
(Gottlieb)).
7. REVIEW AND APPROVE BUILDING AND SITE PLAN AND
CONDITIONAL USE GRANT AMENDMENT FOR A COMMUNITY BASED RESIDENTIAL FACLITY
AT 1521 W. SECOND AVENUE, BONESTOO ROSENE ANDERLIK & ASSOCIATES,
APPLICANT: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff explained to the Commissioners
that this property is located at a dead end portion of Second Avenue
immediately east of CTH LL. The property has been used as a 12-unit
Community Based Residential Facility since it was built in 1993. The
owners are now proposing to build a 1,200 square foot addition that would
add 6 new rooms and 4 additional beds to the facility. The rear and
portions of the east side of the property is fenced; there is on-site
parking for 5 vehicles, but no provision for handicapped parking. The
existing Conditional Use Grant allows for 3 off-street parking stalls. The
Design Review Board reviewed the plans and would like to see a narrower
driveway approach of 32 feet. A 4 foot green space between the sidewalk
and the parking area; landscaping to buffer the parking from the adjacent
residence; curbing in the parking lot; and a place to accommodate the
trash dumpster on the property. There will be 6 parking stalls on the
property and the parking area is 5 feet from the west lot line. The
proposed sign shall be no larger than 6 square feet in size. Mr. Chris
Braun of Bonestroo, Rosene, Anderlik and Associates was present to answer
any questions the Commissioner might have. This proposal is before the
Plan Commission for a recommendation to the Common Council. Commissioner
Dybdahl asked if it met the density requirements. City Planner Tetzlaff
stated that it did. Commissioner Ewig had a problem with the parking
stalls. Alderman Babcock questioned the number of residents at this home.
The owners, Mr. David Landers, stated that they have a waiting list of 4
people right now. He stated the most that they would have living there
would be 13 residents, but they would be licensed for 16 residents.
Alderman Babcock asked if they get a lot of visitors. Mr. Landers stated
only on Holidays and staff meetings. MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND
SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to recommend approval to the Common
Council a Conditional Use Grant amendment to allow up to 16 residents and
the revised Site Plan and staff recommendations. Motion carried; (5
votes aye (Gottlieb, Babcock, Dybdahl, Kelley, Vanden Noven) 1 vote nay (Ewig)).
8. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT AMENDMENT
FOR ELLEN’S HOME, A COMMUNITY BASED RESIDENTIAL FACLITY AT 1521 W. SECOND
AVENUE, DAVID LANDERS, OWNER: The Amendment was recommended for
approval to the Common Council in item #7.
9. REVIEW AND APPROVE ENLARGING PRIVATE GARAGE AT 200
NAUTICA DRIVE, KURT ANDREASEN, OWNER: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff
stated that the owner would like to construct a 10' x 26' addition to his
existing 3-car garage. The new addition would not have a garage door; two
additional windows would be added to enhance the building architecture;
and the building materials would match the existing home. Mr. Andreasen
explained that he inherited a mustang automobile and also has a boat and
would prefer to have them inside the garage and not an eyesore outside. He
also has written permission from all of his adjoining neighbors. The side
yards are 12 feet and 20 feet. Staff recommends approval. MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND SECONDED BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK to approve the site
plan as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
10. PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS:
A. CONTINUED DISCUSSION ON UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT
ORDINANCE: Commissioners continued their discussions on the unified
development ordinance. The Traditional Neighborhood Development was
discussed. The Model Ordinance was discussed along with the State
encouraging the use of some of those elements. Alderman Babcock stated
that Middleton Hills was a good example. He stated that it was nice to see
other choices are available. Mayor Gottlieb asked City Planner Tetzlaff
how he would handle it from a zoning standpoint. City Planner Tetzlaff
stated it would be handled in a Planned Development Overlay. Commissioner
Dybdahl asked City Planner Tetzlaff how he would see the Traditional
Neighborhood in 20 to 30 years. City Planner Tetzlaff stated it would
probably be better and more desirable than most conventional subdivisions
with garage after garage facing the street.
11. PUBLIC COMMENTS AND APPEARANCES: - There was
none.
12. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS
AUTHORIZED BY LAW: There was none.
13. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY to adjourned the meeting at 9:43 p.m.
Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 12,
2002
Roll Call FOR SPECIAL MEETING: Mayor Gottlieb
called a duly convened special meeting of the Plan Commission to order
at 6:35 p.m. Members present at this discussion were: Commissioners Mark
Dybdahl, Bud Sova, Earl Kelley, Gene Ewig, Alderman Burt Babcock, City
Engineer Rob Vanden Noven, City Planner Randy Tetzlaff, and City
Administrator Mark Grams. City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese was
absent and excused.
Public Appearances & Comments: There was none.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT FROM POWER
PLANT CONVERSION PROJECT AT 146 SOUTH WISCONSIN STREET, WE ENERGIES,
APPLICANT: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the Plan
Commissioners that at the last Plan Commission meeting, representatives
of WE Energies reviewed the items and conditions that City Staff had
included in the Conditional Use Grant application. WE Energies agreed to
comply with all items, but several items were still being negotiated,
including the acceptable noise standards and the minimum quantities of
city water to be used.
The City Staff recommended approval of the CUG
subject to the following conditions: 1). Compliance with established
sound levels (refer to attachment titled "Sound Requirements); 2). Hours
of construction, and the delivery/unloading of materials and equipment
are limited to the hours of 7 a.m. and 7 p.m., Monday through Friday;
3). Access to the South Beach will be provided after the new the units
come online via a new roadway. Adequate vehicle turn around and drop-off
will be provided; 4). The new gas line will be constructed at a depth of
not less than five (5) feet under any city roadway and shall cross
perpendicular to such roadways. 5). Final site plan shall conform to the
provisions of the Zoning Ordinance relating to landscaping, lighting,
signage, drainage, erosion control and parking. Documentation of said
compliance will be provided; 6). Security of the facility will be
provided both during construction and will continue after the new units
come online. Ongoing plans for security and emergency response will be
reviewed by the Police Department; 7). Fire protection and emergency
response will adhere to section 5 of the Municipal Code; 8). WE Energies
shall be responsible for, and indemnify the City against all claims,
damages and costs associated with toxic, hazardous, flammable or
combustible materials stored, kept or coming to the premise and for the
removal, confinement, neutralizing, clean-up or remediation of such
materials by persons, firms, agencies, departments, or companies
specializing in such hazardous materials, as per section 5.13.240 of the
Municipal Code; 9). WE Energies will be charged a minimum of 800,000
gallons of water usage per month. Any excess usage will be charged at
the City's then applicable rates; 10). Any wastewater discharge will not
have deleterious effects on the City's wastewater treatment plant,
facilities, equipment, or processes. The volume of wastewater discharged
by the power plant shall not exceed levels that may cause harm to the
operation of the City's plant; 11). WE Energies shall provide a written
report from a qualified expert acceptable to the city verifying that the
cool water discharge from the power plant facility will not impede the
safe recreational use of the West Slip/marina/harbor areas; 12). WE
Energies will work with and receive approval from the Wisconsin
Department of Natural Resources ensuring that the coal dock site and
lagoon area are "clean" and require no environmental remediation. WE
Energies will also provide a written report from a qualified expert
acceptable to the City verifying the condition of the sheet piling and
retaining walls surrounding the facility. Should the City desire to use
the coal dock and "crusher house" for park or other public purposes, WE
Energies shall facilitate their legislative, transfer, or dedication to
the City; 13). All roadways damaged during construction will be repaired
to a condition that existed prior to construction as documented by the
City Engineer.
Mr. Joel Halbrich of WE Energies presented a
PowerPoint presentation on the Port Washington Generating Station
"What's the new plant going to sound like?" Mr. Halbrich explained that
the power plant would be less obtrusive and less noisy that today's
plant. He explained what sound is and the different between dBA's and
dBC's. He informed the Commissioners that existing sound levels were
checked between June 5, 2001 and June 8, 2001 and that these levels were
check at five (5) different locations. The dBA's ranged from 43 to 50
and the dBC's was at 70. These numbers were equal or lower that other
state limits. Mr. Halbrich stated that the actual sound levels would be
lower most of the time. He also stated that with the new plant, the ash
trucks would be gone, the large bulldozer on the coal pile would be gone
and most of the steam blows would be gone.
Commissioners had several concerns. Alderman Babcock
was concern about the noise levels at various heights in the City and
some Commissioners would like to see the testing of noise levels
continue. Commissioner Sova and several Commissioners had concerns
regarding the discharge of water into the West Slip. Mayor Gottlieb
asked about the condition of the coal pile and sheet piling. Some of the
Commissioners also had concerns regarding indemnity claims. Mr. Halbrich
informed the Commissioners that the noise level testing would continue,
the discharge of water into the West Slip would be looked into and a
report would be done on the sheet piling and coal pile. Commissioner
wanted to add to item number 8, regarding claims, the words "or from",
so it would read, "materials stored, kept, or coming to or from the
premises and for the removal." Motion by COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to recommend approval of the Condition Use
Grant as presented by City Staff with the wording change in item 8 to
include "or from" to the Common Council. Motion carried unanimously.
Public Appearances & Comments: There was none.
ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS AUTHORIZED BY LAW:
RECESS.
PLAN COMMISSION WILL RE-CONVENE AT 7:30 P.M. IN
COMMON COUNCIL CHAMBERS FOR A JOINT TOWN AND CITY PLAN COMMISSION
MEETING.
PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION OF PROPOSED LAND USE
CHANGES AND AMENDMENT TO MASTER LAND USE PLAN: Randy Tetzlaff
reviewed the differences in the definitions used by the Town and City
regarding the different land use categories. As requested by the
respective Plan Commissions, a joint definition and in some cases, a new
name or term was presented for each category. He also briefly summarized
the areas of similarity between the respective plans. Larry
Wittzling, town planner, reviewed in detail, the areas where the two
plans differed and suggested land uses for those areas. He also reviewed
the Knellsville area, which is the area where both communities may be
able to work together. After discussion by Commissioners of both
communities, it was decided by consensus, that the planner go back and
draft a joint land use plan that would be reviewed by each community and
later adopted be each. That joint plan would form the basis for future
discussion and cooperation.
ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS AUTHORIZED BY LAW. None.
10. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER VANDEN NOVEN
AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT
9:15
P.M. Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, AUGUST 15, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE: Mayor Gottlieb called
a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to order at 7:00 P.M. to
discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members present at this
discussion were Commissioners Gene Ewig, Earl Kelly, City Engineer Rob
Vanden Noven, City Planner, Randy Tetzlaff, M. Grams, City Administrator
and Building Inspector, Dennis Wiese. Commissioner Sova arrived at 7:25
P.M. City Planner Tetzlaff and the Commissioners discussed Traditional
Neighborhood Developments such as the one covering Middleton Hills,
Wisconsin. This was the first TND for the State of Wisconsin. City
Engineer Rob Vanden Noven discussed Street & Roadway Standards.
Traditional Neighborhood developments have narrower streets than what is
required in conventional subdivisions. Narrow streets help to slow traffic
down to promote pedestrian safety. The commissioners suggested making a
collector street a total of 34 – 50 feet.
1. ROLL CALL FOR REGULAR MEETING: Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened
meeting Sova, R. Vanden Noven, DPW/City Engineer, R. Tetzlaff, Director of
Planning & Development, D. of the Plan Commission to order at 7:35 P.M.
Commission Members Present: G. Ewig, E. Kelley, B. Wiese, Director of
Building Inspection, Mark Grams, City Administrator. Absent & Excused:
Commission Member, Mark Dybdahl, and Alderman Burt Babcock.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF JULY 18TH. MOVED BY
COMMISSIONER EWIG, AND SECONDED BY KELLY TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE
JULY 18TH MEETING AS PRESENTED WITH A CORRECTION TO THE CONSENT
AGENDA ON ITEM 7, UNDER THE MOTION ON PAGE 2, THE WORD STRIPPED SHOULD BE
AMENDED TO READ "STRIPED". Motion carried unanimously.
3. CHAIRMAN’S BUSINESS: Chairman Gottlieb informed the Commissioners
that there will be a joint meeting of the Town Plan Commissioners and the
City of Port Washington Plan Commission on September 12th. The
recent meetings with the Town have gone very well. We will be working to
have both terminology and future uses consistent in both Land Use Plans.
4. PUBLIC APPEARANCES & COMMENTS: Mr. Chuck
Lanser, President of the Port
Washington Soccer Club appeared to inform the Commission that due to
the high cost in developing the Schanen Property and the heavy traffic
that uses Hwy 33 they would like to look for other property that would be
better suited for the Soccer Park.
CONSENT AGENDA:
A. MINOR BUILDING FAÇADE ALTERATION TO THE AMERITECH BUILDING AT 301 W.
GRAND AVENUE, TENG ASSOCIATES, APPLICANT: City Planner Randy
Tetzlaff reviewed with the Commission the plan that was presented by Teng
Associates for the Ameritech building. This building will no longer be
opened to the public and Ameritech would like the building to be more
secured by removing the glass doors and panels and replacing them with
black panels to match the existing black granite. The Design Review has
recommended approving this Minor Building Façade to the Ameritech building
at 301 W. Grand Ave. MOVED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG, SECOND BY COMMISSIONER
SOVA TO APPROVE THE MINOR BUILDING FAÇADE ALTERATION TO THE AMERITECH
BUILDING AS PRESENTED. Motion carried unanimously.
6. REVIEW AND APPROVE SITE PLAN FOR TACO BELL AND SHELL CONVENIENCE
CENTER, W. SEVEN HILLS ROAD, EPPSTEIN UHEN ARCHITECTS, APPLICANT. Mr. Pat
Fehrenbach, Architect appeared and reviewed with the Commission a revised
Site Plan for Taco Bell. This item was tabled in June as the Commissioners
were concerned with the excess parking, location of the trash enclosures
and the size of the pylon sign. The changes to the site plan are as
follows:
Parking count has decreased from 65 to 44 stalls. The drive
thru lane has been moved slightly north and the canopy moved south
to allow for more parking closer to Taco Bell. Parking along the
south side of the canopy has been eliminated. Parking stalls south
of the Shell convenience store have been designed to accommodate
vehicles towing boats or campers.
The trash enclosures have been changed to split face block to
match the building; one enclosure (Shell Gas) has moved from being
close the residences on the southwest side of the building to an
area closer to the shopping center. The enclosure for the Taco
Bell remains in the same location, however, the fence has now been
extended to shield it from the residences. No other practical
location is available to relocate it to. The developer has agreed
to limiting hours of trash pick-up to mitigate the impact of his
location.
The 6’ high wooden fence has been extended around the south
side of the site to within 10’ of the east property line. It is
proposed that a 5’ of the encroaching asphalt be used as a
pedestrian walkway.
The size of the building has decreased allowing both the canopy
and the building to be moved eastward to provide more buffer area
adjacent to the residences and improve internal circulation. The
buffer area has now been increased to a width of 29½ feet and has
been more heavily landscaped.
The landscaping plan as submitted far exceeds what is required
by our ordinance and the new plan increases open space to 35% of
the site.
The lighting plan remains unchanged and is acceptable. The
architect however, indicated that they are trying to incorporate
lighting under the canopy to reduce illumination impact on the
neighborhood. I have encouraged him to do this if possible.
The pylon sign has been replaced with a monument sign that
rests upon a 2 foot, high foundation. The size of the sign is
approximately 8 feet high and 17 feet 10 inches wide. While
somewhat large in size, the proposed sign does conform to the
intent of the Plan Commission.
Alderman Karl Leicht appeared and read a statement from some of the
property owners on both Michael Ct. and Thomas Dr. They are proposing
that the elevation of the fence on the west & south property be raised
to 6 ft. so the top of the fence will be elevated 6 feet with added
support for strength.
The following property owners appeared: Duane Helms, 372 Michael Ct.
and is concerned about the clean-up issue; Chuck Lanser, 396 Michael Ct.
feels that the fence is important for the properties near the project;
and David Mayer, 307 Michael Ct. opposes the gas station and the fence
should be raised higher. Landscaping should be done properly.
Commissioner Sova asked if moving the fence an additional 5 feet
would still allow for landscaping. Pat Fehrenbach replied that there is
still enough room to accommodate the proposed landscaping. Director of
Planning & Development Tetzlaff is recommending approval of the Site &
Operation Plan for Taco Bell. It is also understood that the owners of
the shopping center will accommodate vehicle access and work to improve
pedestrian access to Thomas Dr.
MOVED BY CHAIRMAN GOTTLIEB, SECOND BY EWIG TO APPROVE
THE SITE & OPERATIONAL PLAN FOR TACO BELL/SHELL GAS STATION AS PRESENTED
WITH THE EXCEPTION OF MOVING THE FENCE BACK AN ADDITIONAL 5 FEET AND THE
FENCE WOULD BE 6 FEET IN HEIGHT. Motion carried unanimously.
7. REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT FOR SHELL GAS STATION,
W. SEVEN HILLS RD., EPPSTEIN UHEN ARCHITECTS. Director of Planning &
Development Randy Tetzlaff is recommending approval of the Conditional
Use Grant contingent on the following:
The project shall adhere to the approved site plan;
No semi-trucks or overnight parking allowed:
Storage of outdoor merchandise is prohibited;
Temporary and banner signs are prohibited;
Trash pick-up shall be between the hours of 7 am and 7 pm;
Hours of operation: Gas pumps –24 hours; Convenience store—5:00
am to 10 pm Sunday-Thursday and 5:00 am to midnight on Fridays and
Saturdays; Taco Bell—Hours of operation for Taco Bell dining room
shall be limited to 9:30 am to 10pm every day and the drive thru
shall be 9:30 am to 11 pm Sunday – Thursday, and 9:30 am to
midnight on Fridays and Saturdays.
Conditional Use Grants are subject to review in one year by the
Plan Commission and be extended indefinitely thereafter.
MOVED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA, SECOND BY COMMISSIONER EWIG TO APPROVE
THE CONDITIONAL USE GRANT AS PRESENTED AND ADDING THE PROVISION THAT
DELIVERIES BE LIMITED TO 7 AM – 7 PM. Motion carried unanimously.
8. REVIEW AND APPROVE SITE PLAN FOR THE CONVERSION OF THE POWER PLANT
AT 146 S. WISCONSIN STREET, WE ENERGIES, OWNER. Director of Planning &
Development, Randy Tetzlaff reminded the Commissioners that at the June
meeting WE Energies gave a presentation describing the proposed building
improvements and site plan for the power plant conversion project. Mr.
Doug Wietgen, Mr. Steve Krosik and Mr. Joel Umbrecht appeared on behalf
of WE Energies and presented a new construction site plan. They propose
to keep the ornate north and west facades. The walls are to be
constructed with materials that are compatible with the existing ones.
The height of the building will be increased so that all of the
mechanical equipment currently located on the roof will be covered and
removed from view. All the metal accessory buildings will be removed.
Further discussion took place with regard to the proposed landscaping,
parking, lighting, signage. The Design Review Board has recommended that
more parking be added as well as a better vehicle turn-around area for
the south beach.
In order to stay within the timelines, the Plan Commission must give
tentative approval of the site plan and then recommend approval of the
Conditional Use Grant so the Common Council it can make its
recommendation at the September 17th Council Meeting. A final
plan will not be implemented until at least 2008. WE Energies has agreed
with the Plan Commission to again review the site plan as the project
nears completion.
Permits are pending with the DNR so the bluff area can be returned to
its natural state for the south beach area.
MOVED BY CHAIRMAN GOTTLIEB, SECOND BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN TO
APPROVE THE CONSTRUCTION SITE PLAN AND TENTATIVE APPROVAL FOR THE
BUILDING SITE PLAN FOR WE ENERGIES AS PRESENTED, AND RECOMMEND SAME TO
THE COMMON COUNCIL FOR APPROVAL. Motion carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND A CONDITIONAL USE GRANT FOR THE
POWER PLANT CONVERSION AT 146 S. WISCONSIN STREET, WE ENERGIES,
OWNER. Mr. Joel Umbrecht, reviewed with the Commission the conditions of
the Conditional Use Grant They will be returning to the Plan Commission
when they have finalized the requirements for the Conditional Use Grant.
10. REVIEW AND APPROVE A CONCEPT DEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR NEW
RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENTAT THE SOUTHWEST CORNER OF STH 32 AND E. SAUK
ROAD, FIDUCIARY REAL ESTATE, APPLICANT. Mr. Craig Raddatz of Fiduciary
Real Estate appeared to review with the Commissioners a concept
development plan for a new residential development at the southwest
corner of STH 32 and E. Sauk Road in the Town of Grafton, which is
presently owned by the Luib family. This property is part of a planned
reconstruction of STH 32 and utilities will be extended to the
intersection of E. Sauk Rd. The land shown in their concept plan is
within the City’s sewer service limits, however, the remaining Luib
property and surrounding properties are not. Future development of these
areas will require a sewer service amendment. The City’s Land Use Plan
would have to be amended to reflect the proposed and new project
development. They are proposing 182 condominium units in 4 and 6 unit
buildings and a community center. The majority of the development will
be served with private roads. Many communities are moving in this
direction because it reduces their service costs. Mr. Raddatz described
the three different building styles that were shown in the handout to
the Commissioners. He also stated that the new Concept Plan incorporates
the suggestions made by the Design Review Board. Director of Planning &
Development Randy Tetzlaff stated that if the Plan Commission approves
the concept plan, he is recommending that Staff be directed to begin the
process to amend the Land Use Plan. The developer/owner of this property
may then be interested in pursuing annexation.
MOVED BY COMMISSIONER KELLY, SECOND BY CITY ENGINEER ROB VANDEN NOVEN
TO APPROVE THE CONCEPT PLANS AS PRESENTED. Motion carried. (4-1, Sova,
voting no).
REVIEW AND APPROVE BUSINESS AND OPERATIONAL PLAN FOR A
TATTOO/BODY PIERCING SHOP AT 127 E. WASHINGTON, JESSE SANTORO,
APPLICANT. Mr. Jesse Santoro appeared and is requesting to open a Tattoo
& Body Piercing Shop at 127 E. Washington St. Mr. Santoro has been
tattooing for 6 years and he is licensed through the State of Wisconsin
as well as the State of Iowa. Director of Planning & Development, Randy
Tetzlaff is bringing this item to the Plan Commission for review because
since it is a "customer service establishment" that requires a business
and operational plan. He has checked with other communities and found
that no other communities have developed any special standards and
inspection. The City Attorney has researched this matter and has found
nothing in the Municipal Code or Zoning Ordinance that would prohibit a
tattoo parlor. Mr. Santoro would like to be open from 10:00 a.m. to
10:00 p.m. Staff recommends approval subject to the business complying
with all applicable state regulations.
MOVED BY SOVA, SECOND BY EWIG TO APPROVE THE BUSINESS AND OPERATIONAL
PLAN FOR A TATTOO/BODY PIERCING SHOP AT 127 E. WASHINGTON STREET WITH
PERMITTED HOURS . Motion carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND FINAL CONDOMINIUM PLAT FOR LAKE
POINTE CONDOMINIUMS, HIGHER GROUND, APPLICANT. Director of Planning &
Development, Randy Tetzlaff stated that last year, the Plan Commission
and Common Council reviewed a site plan, condominium plat and easements
for this project. The Plan Commission also reviewed a revised exterior
plans for buildings #3 and #4. A final condominium plat has now been
prepared that reflects all previous approvals. This plat conforms to all
previous approvals and the appropriate condominium documents have also
been prepared. Staff recommends approval. MOVED BY CHAIRMAN GOTTLIEB,
SECOND BY SOVAL TO APPROVE THE FINAL PLAT FOR LAKEPOINTE CONDOMINIUMS
AND RECOMMEND SAME TO THE COMMON COUNCIL FOR APPROVAL. Motion carried
unanimously.
PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS: None
14. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES. None
15. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS COMMISSION AS
AUTHORIZED BY LAW. None
16. MOVED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN, SECOND BY COMMISSIONER KELLY
TO ADJOURN AT 10:10 P.M. Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, JULY 18, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to
order at 7:03 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present at this discussion were: Commissioners Mark Dybdahl, Bud Sova,
Earl Kelley, and Gene Ewig, Alderman Burt Babcock, City Engineer Rob
Vanden Noven, City Planner Randy Tetzlaff, and City Building Inspector
Dennis Wiese. City Administrator Mark Grams arrived at 7:25 p.m. City
Planner Randy Tetzlaff and the Commissioners discussed the side yards and
setbacks for various zoning districts. Commissioners also discussed
Neighborhood Commercial districts. Randy asked the Commissioners for their
comments on this district. There was discussion on what would be the
maximum height in a district. Mayor Gottlieb suggested adding the
statement "Not withstanding the above of 85 feet. No exceptions."
The Industrial Park, Special Regulations, and General Industrial were
discussed.
Roll Call FOR REGULAR MEETING: Mayor Gottlieb
called a duly convened regular meeting of the Plan Commission to order
at 7:30 p.m. All Commissioner members were present.
Approval of Minutes OF JUNE 20TH MEETING:
MOVED BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG TO APPROVE
THE MINUTES AS PRESENT WITH A CORRECT TO THE CONSENT AGENDA 5A. IT
SHOULD BE AMENDED TO READ "ASKED THAT IT BE MOVED TO THE SOUTH OF THE
WALKWAY ON MAIN STREET" INSTEAD OF "A FEW FEET". Motion
carried unanimously.
Chairman’s Business: there was none.
Public Appearances & Comments: There was none.
consent agenda:
CONCEPT PLAN AND FAÇADE ALTERATION TO 222 EAST
MAIN STREET FOR PROPOSED MARITIME HERITAGE CENTER, DAN MCCOTTER,
APPLICANT: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff reviewed this item with
the Plan Commissioners. He stated that Dan McCotter was present
tonight to answer any questions the Commissioners might have. Randy
explained to the Commission that Mr. McCotter would like to convert
the former grocery store space into a maritime heritage center. The
owners of the building had previously planned to convert the space
to retail use and construct an outdoor boardwalk. New windows would
be added facing the lake and there would also be an eastside
entrance. He is also requesting approval to erect two banners (30" x
30") on both the west and east elevations of the building with goose
neck floodlights to illuminate the banners. Mr. McCotter stated that
the Maritime Heritage Center would be open in Spring or Summer of
2003. The fundraising would be starting next month and renovations
would be done over the winter. The Design Review Board recommended
approving this concept plan and the placement of banner subject to
the applicant being responsible for maintenance of the banners and
the banners would be removed after one year. Motion by MAYRO
GOTTIEB and seconded by ALDERMAN BABCOCK to approve the Concept
Plan, Façade Alterations and Banners as presented. Motion carried
unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE SITE AND OPERATIONAL PLAN FOR TACO
BELL AND SHELL CONVENIENCE CENTER AND REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL
USE GRANT FOR GAS STATION, 221 WEST SEVEN HILLS ROAD, EPPSTEIN UHEN
ARCHITECTS, APPLICANT: This item was table per the applicant's
request.
REVIEW AND APPROVE SITE AND OPERATIONAL PLAN FOR AUTO
REPAIR FACILITY AND REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT TO PERMIT
AUTO REPAIR AND ACCESSORY SALES, 925 SOUTH SPRING STREET, RAY FLAHERTY,
OWNER: Randy Tetzlaff explained to the Commissioner at last month
this item was tabled. He stated that the remodeling work is progressing
but not completely done in the former Trimen. It was discussed last
month, the when a new tenant was secured for the former Metro building,
a site plan for that portion would be submitted. Mr. Ray Flaherty, who
is present here tonight, has an interested tenant, Precision Auto. This
is the same company that was interested in the old Schmit Dodge building
on South Park Street. This company is an auto repair business that would
sell and install high-end auto accessories. That use requires a
Conditional Use Grant in the Arterial Gateway Overlay. Mr. Flaherty
plans for the Metro Building include repainting it an off white with a
burgundy mansard roof. The Design Review Board has recommended approval
of this site plan with a number of conditions. Commissioners expressed
concerns about the size of two signs being located on the one property.
Amy Lorence was present at this meeting. She informed the Commissioners
that the sign plans have been submitted to the State for approval, since
the State will be paying for the sign (WDOT is paying for their business
relocation). Commissioner continued their discussion on the signs.
MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK to approve the
Site Plan as presented subject to the following conditions: 1) Wheel
stops are to be provided along the existing landscape area in front of
the building; 2) Details to be provided to the Staff showing either a
raised and continuous curb or spit-face block between proposed parking
stalls and the new raised beds; 3) The paved area to the north be
removed and replaced with seeded grass and that a low level planting
area be located to divide the grass area and the existing paved surface
(ensures 30% open space) and the existing lighting based to be removed;
4) Vertical posts are to be provided along the north edge of the parking
area (to be used by Precision Auto) to prevent vehicle access to the
leftover paved area; 5) A planting bed to be added to the south side of
the building to tie together the previously approved landscaping plan;
6) Parking area to be stripped to designate new parking spaces; and 7)
That there be a maximum of 2 signs on this property for a total face
area of 75 sq. ft. (one ground sign (monument) and one free standing
sign). Motion carried unanimously.
The Conditional Use Grant to Permit Auto Repair and
Accessory Sales was discussed. Randy Tetzlaff informed the
Commissioners that this item was also tabled from last month. The Design
Review Board recommended approval of the Conditional Use Grant with the
following conditions: 1) All existing debris and stored vehicles shall
be removed prior to occupancy; 2) Outdoor storage of vehicles and
materials is strictly prohibited; 3) Occupant may use the existing sign
standard (20 ft. hight/42 sq. ft.) placed as per site plan; 4) No
outside banners or temporary signs; 5) Use is subject to the approved
site plan; and 6) Occupancy shall not be allowed until all aspects of
the approved site plan are completed. Commissioners discussed the
remodeling of this building and the Trimen Building. Commissioner also
discussed when the buildings would be occupied. They would like to see a
timetable of when the painting, landscaping, exterior and interior of
buildings would be completed. MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED
BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to recommend approval of the Conditional Use Grant
to the Common Council subject to the six conditions stated above and no
occupancy to the Metro Building until it is complete remodeled, and the
exterior site work is complete except for seeding. Also there will be no
occupancy of the Trimen Building until the conditions approved at the
May meeting are completed. Commissioners Dybdahl and Sova were impressed
with what has been completed so far. Motion Carried Unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE CERTIFIED SURVEY MAP FOR PROPERTY
ON GARAY LANE, KENNETH MILLER, APPLICANT: Randy Tetzlaff explained
to the Commissioners that last year the Commission approved plans by Ken
Miller for condominiums and apartments on Garay Lane. There are three
existing lots and Mr. Miller would now like to readjust the lot lines.
This would create three new parcels. These new lots reflect the
placement of the buildings and approved site plan. This is basic a house
keeping measure. The Design Review Board recommends approval. MOTION
BY COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY to approve as
presented. Motion Carried Unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE CERTIFIED SURVEY MAP FOR CITY
OWNED PROPERTY LOCATED ON NORTH PARK STREET: Randy Tetzlaff informed
the Commissioners that this is the lot that the City has approved to
sell to Habitat for Humanity. The land parcel and street were all
described as City property; the surveyor delineated the street R. O. W.
as being 30 feet from the centerline of North Park Street. The Design
Review Board recommends approval. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve as presented. Motion Carried
Unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE AMENDING A CONDITIONAL USE GRANT
AT 101 EAST GRAND AVENUE TO PERMIT OUTDOOR FOOD SERVICE, COUSIN'S SUBS,
APPLICANT: Randy Tetzlaff informed the Commissioners that Cousin's
Subs would like to place metal tables and chairs in front of their
business to serve food. The sidewalk is private property and ranges from
8 feet to 12 feet. Recently, a Conditional Use Grant was approved for
this property on behalf of Crème City Coffee. The City Attorney advises
that the amended Conditional Use Grant be considered and would include
the following language. 1) Provision for up to eight (8) tables; 2)
Tables shall be placed in an area no farther than eight (8) feet from
the building; 3) No doors or exits shall be blocked; and 4) Refuse
containers shall be provided for customers. The Design Review Board
recommends approval with those 4 conditions. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER
SOVA AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL to recommend approval to the
Common Council to amend the existing Conditional Use Grant to permit
outdoor food service with the 4 conditions. Commissioners discussed
this item. City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese had concerns regarding
the fire exits and the tables on the sidewalk. Commissioner Sova
withdrew his motion and Commissioner Dybdahl withdrew his second.
MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to recommend
approval to the Common Council to amend the existing Conditional Use
Grant to permit outdoor food service with the following conditions: 1)
Provision for up to eight (8) tables; 2) Tables shall be placed in an
area no farther than eight (8) feet from the building; 3) Refuse
containers shall be provided for customers; and (4) No doors or exits
shall be blocked and the City Building Inspector shall review the
required fire exit paths. Motion Carried Unanimously.
PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS:
The discussion on the Unified Development Code
continued. Randy Tetzlaff discussed with the Commissioners the
Traditional Neighborhoods. Mayor Gottlieb asked that City Engineer
Vanden Noven review page 53. Commissioners were asked to look very
closely at the Use Table and at the next meeting the Use Table would
be discussed.
12. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES: There was none.
13. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS AUTHORIZED BY LAW. Judy Klumb, Recording Secretary for
the Plan Commission, asked the Commissioners to review and comment on a
shorten version of the minutes. The Commissioners would prefer a version
that is not as brief as the one presented but not a long drawn out version
either. They would prefer something in the middle. The minutes should show
the motion plus a brief commentary on the discussion of the issue.
14. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 9:02 P.M.
Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, JUNE 20, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to
order at 7:04 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present at this discussion were: Commissioners Mark Dybdahl, Bud Sova,
Earl Kelley, and Gene Ewig, Alderman Burt Babcock, City Planner Randy
Tetzlaff, and City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese. Absent and excused:
City Administrator Mark Grams and City Engineer Rob Vanden Noven. City
Planner Randy Tetzlaff and the Commissioners discussed various zoning
districts. Commissioners also discussed the setbacks and side yards. They
asked if staff would review this item and bring it back to Plan
Commission.
7:30 P.M. Roll Call FOR REGULAR MEETING: Mayor
Gottlieb called a duly convened regular meeting of the Plan Commission to
order at 7:31 p.m. All Commissioner members were present except for City
Engineer Rob Vanden Noven and City Administrator Mark Grams.
Approval of Minutes OF MAY 16TH MEETING: MOVED BY
COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG TO APPROVE THE MINUTES
AS PRESENTED. Motion carried unanimously.
Chairman’s Business: Mayor Gottlieb welcomed
everyone to the new Council Chambers. He also updated the Commissioners on
the boundary discussions with the Town of Port Washington. He also advised
the Commissioners and the audience that we have a crowded agenda tonight
and that we all should stay on track.
Public Appearances & Comments: There was none.
consent agenda:
DESIGN PLANS FOR THE HISTROIC MARITIME EXHIBIT, EAST
MAIN STREET AND THE WEST SLIP: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff reviewed
this item with the Plan Commissioners. He stated that the Maritime
Experience is proposing to construct its first exhibit on the harbor walk
area along the North Slip and at the end of East Main Street. The Design
Review Board recommended approval of the site plan as presented. Mr. Dan
McCotter was present to answer any questions the Plan Commissioners had.
The Plan Commissioners were very excited about this proposed construction
and asked that it be moved a few feet to the south. Motion by
COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL and seconded by COMMISSIONER KELLEY to approve the
Site Plan was presented on the condition that the exhibit is moved a few
feet to the south. Motion carried unanimously.
SITE PLAN FOR NEW TESTING FACILITY FOR OMNIQUIP,
MINERAL SPRINGS ROAD: City Pl anner Randy Tetzlaff reviewed this
item with the Plan Commissioners. He stated that OmniQuip is transferring
jobs and work from Egan, MN, along with the transfer is the need to
provide a facility to test military equipment. The Design Review Board had
a concern that part of the testing facility is on property owned by
Superior Special Services and land that may be used for future expansion
by Mr. Z's. A letter of understanding from Superior has been submitted and
a letter is forthcoming from OmniQuip indicating their understanding that
if and when Mr. Z's wants to expand, the test facility area will need to
be modified. The Design Review Board recommends approval of the site plan
as presented contingent upon receipt of a letter of understanding from
OmniQuip. Mr. Mike Erhlich was present to answer any questions the
Commissioners had. MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY
COMMISSIONER KELLEY to approve the site plan as presented contingent upon
receipt of a letter of understanding from OmniQuip. Motion carried
unanimously.
REMODELING PLANS FOR THE HARBORMASTER BUILDING, PORT
WASHINGTON MARINA : City Planner Tetzlaff informed the Plan
Commissioners that the Harbormaster needs additional space and an
observation area. The plans include adding a second-story dormer with
windows to the west elevation of the building. The Design Review Board
recommends approval of the remodeling plans as presented. MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER EWIG AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to approve the
remodeling plans as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
CONCEPTUAL DISCUSSION OF SITE PLAN FOR THE POWER PLANT
CONVERSION, KAHLER SLATER ARCHITECTS, INC., APPLICANT. City Planner
Tetzlaff informed the Commissioners that WE Energies and WE Power would be
here tonight to present their conceptual plan of the Power Plant
conversion. Joel M. Haubrich showed the Commissioners a series of
architect’s renderings that showed what the site would look like after the
plant was converted from coal-fire to natural gas. Mr. Haubrich said that
the site would look a lot cleaner than it does today. The biggest changes
would be to the coal dock, which is now occupied by the coal pile. This
area would be available for public access. It could be developed into an
athletic field for soccer and/or baseball. There would also be an area
available for possibly an amphitheater or festival grounds. Mr. Steve
Greiczek, the architect for the project, stated that one of the goals of
the project is to preserve as much of the existing power plant as
possible. Every effort would be made to make sure that the new
construction matches the existing building. The two smokestacks would be
remodeled into four smaller smokestacks. The utility also plans to turn
over the three-story high-pressure house to the city for use as a
concession stand or for public meetings. The coal dock could be used to
draw tourists to the City by bring cruise ships into the harbor. Mr.
Greiczek stated that this is a great potential for the Community. When
construction is completed, there will be better public access to the south
beach. The Commissioners were very excited about the concept plan. Lloyd
Smith of 1312 West Grand Avenue commented that this compliments the City.
The new construction road should be the same width as South Wisconsin
Street. MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK to
approve the Conceptual Site Plan for the Power Plant. Motion Carried
Unanimously.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND SITE PLAN FOR TACO BELL AND SHELL
CONVENIENCE CENTER AND REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT
FOR GAS STATION, 221 EAST SEVEN HILLS ROAD, EPPSTEIN UHEN ARCHITECTS,
APPLICANT: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff explained to the Commissioners
that back in the fall of 2000, a site plan and Conditional Use Grant was
approved for a Mobil gas convenience center and car wash on the outlot in
front of the Northport Shopping Center. A new developer is now proposing a
combined Taco Bell and Shell Convenience Center and no car wash. The
Design Review Board reviewed the plan and expressed the following
concerns: 1) more parking required than code; 2) no room provided for
vehicle stacking near the exit; 3) no secondary egress from the site; 4)
no pedestrian access; 5) location of some landscaping and 6) the massive
size of the freestanding sign near the entrance (34 feet in height and 288
square feet in size). The Design Review Board recommends approval of the
revised site plan as presented with the following contingencies: that the
items 2 through 5 be addressed adequately and that the Plan Commission
agrees on a compromise height and size of the freestanding sign. The
Design Review Board also recommends approval of the Conditional Use Grant
contingent upon the following: 1) The project shall adhere to the approved
site plan; 2) No semi-trucks or overnight parking allowed (except for
employees); 3) Storage of outdoor merchandise is prohibited; 4) Temporary
and banner signs are prohibited; and 5) Conditional Use Grant is subject
to review in one (1) year by the Plan Commission and may be extended
indefinitely thereafter. Mr. Patrick H. Fehrenbach from Eppstin Uhen, the
architects working on this project and Mr. Scott Eucker, the developer,
were present to answer any questions the Commissioners might have.
Commissioners discussed this item. They had concerns with too much
parking, trash containers and some of the landscaping. The Mayor opened
the floor for public comments on this item. Ann Volesky of 426 Thomas
Drive said that she was opposed to this project. Mr. Friz Prange of 379
Thomas Drive was opposed to it but would like to see more landscaping. He
has the duplexes next to this property and he would be willing to sell his
trees to the developers. Mr. John Weinrich of 1757 North Holden Street was
opposed to this project. Alderman Babcock stated that the number of points
on the landscape plan looked good. David Mayer of 307 Michael Court had a
number of complaints about this project. He was opposed to it; he was
worry about security and land values; he was concerned about traffic and
lighting; he would like to see an upscale restaurant in this location; and
he had several other issues with this project. Dennis Budd of 314 Thomas
Drive was opposed to such a large development. He wanted to know why we
could not have just the fast food and not the gas station and convenience
store. He would like to see a larger buffer between the residents and this
development. He would like to see the whole area fenced in. Duane Helms of
301 Michael Court was opposed to this development also. He already has
garbage from the shopping center flying into his yard and he is tired of
picking up their mess. He would also like to see it fence in all around.
Commissioners again
concerns with the first proposal and he still has
concerns with this project. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to table this
Site Plan. MOTION FAILED FOR LACK OF A SECOND. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER
KELLEY AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve the revised Site Plan
subject to moving the trash containers to a better location. 2 Aye’s
(Kelley & Ewig) and 4 Nay’s (Gottlieb, Babcock, Sova and Dybdahl).
Motion denied. MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER
SOVA to table this Site Plan to the next meeting. 5 Aye’s (Gottlieb,
Kelley, Babcock, Sova, and Ewig) and 1 Nay (Dybdahl). Motion Carried.
Commissioners briefly discussed the Conditional Use
Grant for the Taco Bell and Shell Gas Station. They were concerned with
the hours of operation for the restaurant and gas station. The Design
Review Board and the police department were not concerned about the hours.
It was suggested that staff review the hours of operations for the fast
food restaurants in the area. The Conditional Use Grant would again be
brought up at the next meeting.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT TO SERVE
BEVERAGES OUTDOORS AT 102 EAST GRAND AVENUE, MARSHA ENDICOTT, OWNER:
City Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the Commissioners that Marsha
Endicott was requesting to amend her Conditional Use Grant that was
granted in June of 2002. Her restaurant would like to serve liquor
outdoors. All other conditions of the previous Grant would remain in
effect. The Design Review Board recommends approval. MOTION BY ALDERMAN
BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to recommend approval to the
Common Council to amend the existing Conditional Use Grant to permit
serving of beverages outdoors. Motion Carried Unanimously.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND SITE PLAN FOR AUTO REPAIR FACILITY
AND REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT TO PERMIT AUTO REPAIR AND
ACCESSORY SALES, 925 SOUTH SPRING STREET, RAY FLAHERTY, OWNER: City
Planner Randy Tetzlaff reminded the Commissioners that last November the
Commission reluctantly approved a site plan for the part of Ray Flaherty’s
property of South Spring Street for the former Trimen Building. That plan
included façade renovation, parking and landscaping. The landscaping in
the parkway along the entire length of the property was also approved.
None of this has been started. Mr. Flaherty now has an interested tenant,
Precision Auto that would repair autos and sell and install high-end auto
accessories. The Design Review Board was not pleased with Mr. Flaherty
lack of progress on this property. He was informed the work must progress
before the Plan Commission meets. Mr. Flaherty submitted a new site plan
that the Design Review Board found to be unsatisfactory. It was suggested
that he submit a revised plan the included both buildings. The Design
Review Board held a special meeting to review Mr. Flaherty’s new revised
site plan. The Design Review Board recommended approving the Site Plan
with the following contingencies: 1) Wheel stops be provided along the
existing landscaped area in-front of the building; 2) Details to be
provided to the Plan Commission showing either a raised and continuous
curb or a split-face block between proposed parking stalls and the raised
bed; 3) The paved area to the north be removed and replaced with seeded
grass and that low level planting area be located to divide the grass area
and the existing paved surface (ensures 30% open space); 4) Vertical posts
be provided along the north edge of the parking area (to be used by
Precision Auto) to prevent vehicle access to the left-over paved area; 5)
A planting bed to be added to the south side of the building to tie
together the previously approved landscaping plan; 6) Sign (20’ high and
42 sq. ft.) location to be shown on the plan; 7) Parking area to be
stripped to designate new parking spaces; 8) A timetable for completion
for both projects shall be submitted to the Plan Commission on June 20,
2000; and 9) All work is to be completed on both projects by September 1,
2002; otherwise, the building inspector shall order all premises to be
vacated. Mr. Ray Flaherty and Mr. Randy Meyer were present to discuss the
site plan and the landscaping plan. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL to table this project until next month’s
meeting and have staff and developer review this project in depth. 4 Aye’s
(Kelley, Dybdahl, Ewig, and Babcock) and 2 Nay’s (Gottlieb and Sova).
Motion Carried.
REVIEW AND APPROVE CERTIFIED SURVEY MAP FOR PW
INVESTMENTS, INC. BYWATER BUSINESS CENTER. City Planner Randy Tetzlaff
informed the Commissioners that the lots in the Bywater Business Park were
originally created when Paul Wiese purchased the property from GardenWay.
This Certified Survey Map involves the realignment of lot lines involving
Lots 4, 5, and 7. Under the proposed survey, new lots 1, 2, and 3 will be
created. Staff recommends approval. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND
SECONDED BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK to approve the Certified Survey Map as
presented. Motion Carried Unanimously.
11. PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS: There was none.
12. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES: There was none.
13. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS
AUTHORIZED BY LAW. There was none.
14. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 9:56 P.M.
Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, MAY 16, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to
order at 7:03 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present at this discussion were: Commissioners Bud Sova, Earl Kelley, Gene
Ewig, Mark Dybdahl, City Engineer Rob Vanden Noven, City Planner Randy
Tetzlaff, and City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese. Alderman Burt Babcock
arrived at 7:27 p.m. and Commissioner City Administrator Mark Grams was
absent and excused. City Planner Randy Tetzlaff discussed with the
Commissioners the downtown overlay district. The height and non-conforming
buildings were discussed. The Rural Estate district was discussed to
replace the Agriculture district. A Special Regulations district was
discussed but Commissioners were not interested. They thought it would be
hard to regulate. The width sizes of lots were discussed by the
Commissioners for the various districts. All parking lots in various
districts should have curbing language.
7:30 P.M. Roll Call FOR REGULAR MEETING:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened regular meeting of the Plan
Commission to order at 7:30 p.m. All Commissioner members were present.
Approval of Minutes OF APRIL 18TH MEETING:
MOVED BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG TO
APPROVE THE MINUTES AS PRESENT. Motion carried unanimously.
Chairman’s Business: There was none.
Public Appearances & Comments: There was none.
consent agenda:
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND FRONT FAÇADE RENOVATION AT
318-320 NORTH FRANKLIN STREET, EMERALD ISLE, LLC, PETER AND LAURA BURKE,
OWNERS: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff reviewed this item with the Plan
Commissioners. He stated that the Design Review Board held a special
meeting on May 15th to discuss revisions to the façade and
make a recommendation for the former Home Port Design building. The
Laura Burke Agency needs plan approval in order to have occupancy on
June 15th. The Burkes have purchased this building to be used
as offices. The front façade has a 1950’s era brick on the top that is
difficult to match, the windows need replacing and the entire lower
level facade needs to be rebuilt. A new sign will be a board sign with
the American Family logo and black letter with a white background.
Commissioners discussed the changes to the front façade and the new
signage. Motion by commissioner sova and SECONDED by city engineer
rob vanden noven to approve the Site Plan was presented. Motion
carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE BUSINESS, SITE AND OPERATIONAL
PLAN FOR JAB ON BYWATER DRIVE, TED BURBACH, OWNER: City Planner
Randy Tetzlaff reviewed this item with the Plan Commissioners. Kraig
Sadownikow of American Building Systems presented plans for a new 8,700
sq. ft. office and warehouse facility for JAB, an overhead door
operation. There is a possibility of future expansion with a 20,000 sq.
ft. addition in about 2 years. The office building would be constructed
of gray split face block with red banding and would be prominent on the
corner of Maritime and Bywater. A monument sign would be erected. The
parking lot would have curbing and also along the island and entrance.
The landscaping plan exceeds the points required. This company would
employ about 12 employees. The Design Review Board recommended approval.
MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL to
approve the site plan as presented Motion carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE BUSINESS, SITE AND OPERATIONAL
PLAN FOR MISTER Z’S ON BYWATER DRIVE, STEVE WINKERS, OWNER: City
Planner Randy Tetzlaff informed the Plan Commissioners that Mister Z’s
had been before the Plan Commission several months ago and that they had
received approval but the Mayor was concern about receiving approval
from the DNR. Mister Z’s owners have since decided to move their new
facility to the other side of the street. This new facility will be
north of the JAB offices and warehouse. This building will be a
combination of office and warehouse and will be 33,000 sq. ft. in size.
An additional 21,000 sq. ft. expansion is planned for the future. The
building will have masonry exterior on the lower part of the structure
on all walls except the expandable east wall. The colored banding will
also be added to the three walls. The parking is sufficient. The
landscaping exceeds our point requirement. The Commissioners also
discussed the lighting fixtures. There are some concerns about the
northeast corner of the lot being used by Trak International. This is
not a problem now because Paul Wiese owns all of the land including the
Trak facility. If Mister Z’s expanse, Trak will need to vacate the land.
Mister Z’s employs 25 employees and during the busy season could employ
up to 30 employees. Commissioners also discussed the parking lot and
signage. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER
SOVA to approve the site plan as presented with the adjusted driveway
entrance to allow for tractor-trailers and a new CSM. Motion carried
unanimously.
APPROVAL OF THE DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MINUTES OF MAY 7TH
AND MAY 15TH, 2002:
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT FOR GARDEN
PATIO SERVING FOOD AND BEVERAGES LOCATED AT 135 EAST GRAND AVENUE, PORT
WASHINGTON, LLC, OWNER: City Planner Tetzlaff informed the
Commissioners that Cathy Wilger representing the Harborside Motor Inn
would like to utilize the existing outdoor patio area to serve food and
beverages weather permitting. Food and beverages had been served there
in past years. The property is zoned B-4 Central Business District.
Outdoor eating and drinking is permitted with a Conditional Use Grant.
The patio area is a perfect location for the proposed use allowing hotel
guests to view activities in the west slip area. The Design Review Board
recommend approval with the following conditions: 1) Hours of operation
to be limited 7:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m.; 2) Use of the patio garden for
eating and drinking be limited to seasonal use from Memorial Day to the
last weekend in September; 3) Maximum patron capacity of the patio
garden is 30 persons; 4) Signage to be posted reminding patrons to not
carry-out beverages from the premises; 5) Refuse containers be provided
to discourage patrons from leaving the premises with food and beverages;
and 6) The Conditional Use Grant will be in effect for 18 months, to be
reviewed by the Plan Commission at which time it may be continued
without limit if there are no documented problems. Commissioners
discussed this issue and decided that it was a great idea and would
enhance the harbor area. MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY
CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to recommend approval to the Common Council
for the Conditional Use Grant subject to the conditions recommended by
the Design Review Board. Motion Carried Unanimously.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CONDITIONAL USE GRANT TO SERVE
FOOD AND BEVERAGES OUTDOORS AT 101 EAST GRAND AVENUE, TIMBERCREEK
DEVELOPMENT, APPLICANT: City Planner Tetzlaff informed the
Commissioners that the plans approved for Harbor Square included an
outdoor deck on the southeast corner of the main floor. Cream City
Coffee will be occupying the space and making use of the outdoor deck.
Cream City Coffee will be serving coffee and lunches. It is a perfect
location overlooking the west slip. The Design Review Board recommended
approval with the following conditions: 1) Hours of operation be limited
to 7:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m.; 2) Maximum patron capacity of the outdoor
deck is 25 persons; 3) Refuse containers be provided to help prevent
materials from blowing off the premises; and 4) The Conditional Use
Grant will be in effect for 18 months, to be reviewed by the Plan
Commission at which time it may be continued without limit if there are
no documented problems. Commissioners discussed the hours of the outside
deck. Commissioners changed the recommendation from the Design Review
Board to read, the hours of operation shall be limited to the hours the
business is open. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY
COMMISSIONER EWIG to recommend approval to the Common Council for the
Conditional Use Grand subject to the new business hours. Motion
Carried Unanimously.
9. PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS:
CONTINUED DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT
ORDINANCE: Commissioner continued their discussion on the
Traditional Neighborhood Development. They discussed opting for design
guidelines and restrictive covenant. The Commissioners also discussed
the Model Ordinance. The Commissioners were asked to review the table
and how it is treated within each district.
10. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES: There was none.
11. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS
AUTHORIZED BY LAW. The Mayor informed the
Commissioners that the City Common Council had met with the Town of Port
Washington Town Board in a joint meeting. It was a very good discussion.
All the lawsuits between the City and the Town have been cancelled. The
incorporation lawsuit has also been dismissed. The City and Town have
decided to met and discuss the framework for long term needs. The City and
Town staff would research different agreements and discuss maybe sharing
library, senior center and park and recreation facilities.
12. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER EWIG AND
SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER DYBDAHL TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 8:40 P.M.
Motion carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
THURSDAY, APRIL 18, 2002
DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened meeting of the Plan Commission to
order at 7:00 p.m. to discuss the Unified Development Ordinance. Members
present at this discussion were: Alderman Burt Babcock, Commissioners Bud
Sova, Earl Kelley, Gene Ewig, City Engineer Rob Vanden Noven, City Planner
Randy Tetzlaff, and City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese. City
Administrator Mark Grams arrived at 7:27 p.m. and Commissioner Mark
Dybdahl was absent and excused. City Planner Randy Tetzlaff revisited last
month's discussion on the Design Review Board. He reviewed the changes to
the Design Review Board. The Plan Commissioners also discussed the Consent
Agenda. They discussed how and when to remove items from the Consent
Agenda and place them on the regular Plan Commission meeting. Any Plan
Commissioner could ask for a Consent Agenda item to be removed from the
Consent Agenda and be placed on the regular Plan Commission meeting agenda
to be discussed. City Planner Tetzlaff also discussed the different zoning
districts such as R-1, CCM, etc. Commissioners also discussed the
formatting of the districts. Commissioners generally had no complaints
about the formatting. Discussion of Traditional Neighborhoods would be
done in later in the meeting.
7:30 P.M. Roll Call FOR REGULAR MEETING:
Mayor Gottlieb called a duly convened regular meeting of the Plan
Commission to order at 7:30 p.m. All Commissioner members were present
except for Commissioner Dybdahl.
Approval of Minutes OF MARCH 21ST MEETING: MOVED BY
COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY TO APPROVE THE
MINUTES AS PRESENT. Motion carried unanimously.
Chairman’s Business: Mayor Gottlieb welcomed back
Commissioner Sova for another term on the Plan Commission. The Common
Council confirmed his reappointment at their last meeting.
Public Appearances & Comments: There was none.
consent agenda:
REVIEW AND APPROVE SITE PLAN FOR STORAGE SHED AT
THE COUNTY HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT, 316 SOUTH SPRING STREET, OZAUKEE
COUNTY, OWNER: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff reviewed this item
with the Plan Commissioners. The County Highway Department would
like to constructed a metal clad, 3-sided storage shed on the east
side of the highway department property near the railroad tracks.
The building would not have heat and electricity. It would enclose
some of the material and equipment now stored outside. Mr. Mark
Banton, from the Highway Department, was present for any questions.
The Design Review Board recommended approval. Motion by Mayor
Gottlieb and seconded by COMMISSIONER SOVA to approve the Site Plan
was presented. Motion carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE FRONT FAÇADE RENOVATION AT 313
WEST GRAND AVENUE, KEN NASON, OWNER: City Pl anner Randy
Tetzlaff reviewed this item with the Plan Commissioners. He stated
that the owner, Ken Nason, presented plans to add lighted boxes
above the three windows and doors. Mr. Nason also wanted to add one
3' x 5' ground-mount sign with ground flood lights and a 4' x 5'
wall mount sign on the west side of his building using existing
illumination. The signs would be used by future building tenants.
The Design Review Board recommended approval. Commissioners were
concerned with the ground sign and lighting. MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve the
site plan as presented minus the exterior ground-mount sign and
ground floodlights. Motion carried unanimously.
R EVIEW AND APPROVE FRONT FACADE
RENOVATIONS AT 219 NORTH FRANKLIN STREET, BARNEY BANNON, OWNER:
City Planner informed the Plan Commissioners that Mr. Bannon plans
to remove the existing first floor façade materials and replace with
a new window and cream city brick. Mr. Bannon intends to make
improvements that are more compatible with the historic appearance.
The existing sign and bracket would remain. The Design Review Board
was concerned with the new window and door transom be of the same
horizontal height. The Board also wanted a window mull be placed at
height even with the top of the doors and that an architectural
detail be added above the new window and door transom. Commissioners
were concern about the window being so large. Mayor Gottlieb stated
that the Police prefer a larger window. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER
BABCOCK AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER EWIG to approve the site plan
as presented. Motion carried unanimously.
review and approve business, site, and
operational plan for authomtive repair and acessories, 109 south
park street, mike schmit, owner: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff
reviewed this item with the Plan Commissioners. He informed the
Commissioners that the applicant, Jonathan Ulik, is a tenant of Mike
Schmit, who owns the property. Mr. Ulik would like to convert the
former Dodge dealership into a full-service automotive repair and
high-end accessory business. He intends to repaint the building and
install a 3' x 8' wall mount sign on the Park Street façade and a 3'
x 9' sign atop the existing sign pole on the corner of Park and
Grand. The building needs a lot of work. Landscaping will be needed
to be done along the Park Street frontage and along the Grand Avenue
parking lot. Building Inspector Dennis Wiese stated that the
building is violating building code ordinances. He stated that the
garage is legal but the tavern is not. It is a non-conforming
structure and several code issues need to be cleaned up.
Commissioners discussed this issue at great lengths. MOTION BY
MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to table this item.
Motion carried unanimously.
review and approve building and site plan for 815
sunset road, neil dinesen, owner: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff
reviewed the history of this item with the Plan Commissioners. He
explained that Mr. Dinesen purchased the former Smith Brothers Fish
Processing building and received concept approval from the Plan
Commissioners for two small additions to the building. The new
additions are for a tank room and a container room. The building
material will be similar to the existing building. The Design Review
Board recommended approval. Mr. Tim Bach was present to explain the
building. He stated that this building was the container room and
would hide dumpsters from being seen outside. He also stated that
the building would be a combination of 1/3 metal wall panel, 1/3
pre-engineered metal and 1/3 masonry. Commissioners wanted to see
masonry around the bottom 4 feet of the new building. MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY EWIG to approve the site plan as
presented with the Container Building Addition to have 4 feet split
face block on all three sides. 3 Aye (Sova, Kelley, Ewig) and 3 Nays
(Babcock, Vanden Noven, Gottlieb). Motion Failed.
Commissioner again discussed this item. Some Commissioners suggested
that this addition would be better and a gated corral for dumpsters.
MOTION BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK to approve site plan with a banding
(horizontal paint) on the east elevation above a 4 foot split face
brick. Commissioners discussed this issue again and the Motion
was withdrawn because there was no second. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER
EWIG AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER SOVA to approve the site plan as
presented but with a 3 foot 4 inch split face brick on all three
sides and an 8-inch band of color (smooth accent brick band) to
accent the brick. Motion carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE EXTERIOR BUILDING PLANS FOR
LAKE POINTE CONDOMINIUMS, NORTH WISCONSIN STREET, HIGHER GROUND,
OWNER: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff reviewed this item
with the Plan Commissioners. He explained that the Plan Commission
had approved the Condo Plat, Site Plan and the building plans but
not the last duplex. This building was initially proposed for future
construction, but now the developers would like to proceed with
approval. This building would have a lookout on the third level and
would be constructed of the same materials and color hues as the
other three. The Design Review Board recommends approval. MOTION
BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY CITY ENGINEER VANDEN NOVEN to
approve the exterior building plans as presented. Motion carried
unanimously.
REVIEW AND APPROVE BUILDING AND SITE PLAN FOR
FISH CLEANING STATION AND PUBLIC RESTROOMS ON SOUTH WISCONSIN
STREET, CITY OF PORT WASHINGTON, OWNER: City Engineer Rob Vanden
Noven informed the Plan Commissioners that the fish cleaning station
and public restrooms building would be built adjacent to the old
lift station on South Wisconsin Street. This structure would be now
be freestanding because a sewer is located under the former
location. The restrooms would face the bike trail to the south and
the fish cleaning station will face Wisconsin Street. Commissioners
discussed this whether this would be a 3 seasons or 4-season
building. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER EWIG AND SECONDED BY NOONE to
approve the Site Plan as presented. Motion dies for lack of a
second. City Planner Tetzlaff explained that the building would
be built of cut block on the exterior and painted wood will be used
on the gable ends and fascia. Landscaping will be primarily around
the foundation of the structure because the remainder of the site is
grass with an existing tree. The Design Review Board recommends
approval of the revised building and site plan for the fish cleaning
station and public restrooms on South Wisconsin Street with the
following conditions: the roof pitch and shingle color match the
adjacent lift station; that the cut block color be compatible with
the lift station and that a smooth block banding be used; that a
hard surface be provided on at least three sides of the new
structure; and the structure be located within the required setbacks
and space be provided on the southeast corner of the site for a
future bicycle trail rest stop area. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA
AND SECONDED BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB to approve the Building and Site Plan
with the recommendations from the Design Review Board.
Commissioner Kelley asked if there could be more toilets in the
ladies room. City Building Inspector Dennis Wiese stated that it
needed to be ADA accessible. City Planner Randy Tetzlaff stated that
the Design Review minutes were incorrect and it should be the
southwest corner not the southeast corner for the future bicycle
trail rest stop area. MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY
COMMISSIONER KELLEY TO AMEND THE MOTION TO READ SOUTHWEST
CORNER AND NOT THE SOUTHEAST CORNER. Motion for the
Amendment: Motion carried unanimously. Original
Motion: Motion carried unanimously.
APPROVAL OF THE DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MINUTES OF
APRIL 9, 2002: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER SOVA AND SECONDED BY ALDERMAN
BABCOCK. Motion carried unanimously.
REVIEW AND RECOMMEND CERTIFIED SURVEY MAP FOR 121
NORTH MAPLE STREET, ANGELO LOPEZ, OWNER: City
Planner Tetzlaff explained to the Commissioners that the house on this
property is on lot 1 and the garage is on lot 2. The owner would like to
tear down the garage and build a new home on lot 2. The house on lot 1
would be turned into a rental unit. Commissioners questioned the side
yard setbacks. They also questioned if the drawing was to scale.
MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK to approve the
Certified Survey Map as presented subject to all non-conforming
structures be removed within one year. Motion Carried Unanimously.
CONSIDER AND DECLARE CITY OWNED LAND AS SURPLUS
PROPERTY: City Planner Randy Tetzlaff explained to the Commissioners
that the property located at the corner of North Park Street and Moore
Road was being considered for a Habitat for Humanity project. All this
means is that this body must declare this property as surplus. It then
needs to be rezoned. Staff recommends that this property be declared as
surplus. MOTION BY MAYOR GOTTLIEB AND SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY
to declare the property located at the corner of North Park Street and
Moore Road as surplus City property. Motion Carried Unanimously.
9. PLAN COMMISSION AFFAIRS:
CONTINUED DISCUSSION OF THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT
ORDINANCE: Commissioner continued their
discussion on the Traditional Neighborhood.
10. PUBLIC COMMENTS/APPEARANCES: There was none.
11. ANY OTHER BUSINESS THAT MAY COME BEFORE THIS
COMMISSION AS
AUTHORIZED BY LAW. There was none.
12. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION BY COMMISSIONER KELLEY AND
SECONDED BY ALDERMAN BABCOCK TO ADJOURN THE MEETING AT 9:15 P.M. Motion
carried unanimously.
Table of Contents
|